You called a “we buy houses” number, or you’re thinking about it, and you’re wondering: “How do they come up with that number? Is it fair? Am I leaving money on the table?” Those are good questions. The truth is, a real cash offer isn’t pulled out of thin air. It’s simple math, and once you see it, you can judge any offer you get, from us or anyone else.
Rather talk it through than read? Call or text Darren at 859-549-4700 (Northern Kentucky) or 513-286-3900 (Cincinnati). We’re happy to walk you through your own numbers.
The basic formula
Almost every investor who buys houses to fix up starts with the same four pieces:
- ARV (After Repair Value): what the house could sell for once it’s fixed up, based on similar homes that have recently sold nearby.
- Repairs: what it would cost to bring the house up to that level.
- Costs: closing costs, taxes, insurance and utilities during the work, and the commissions and fees to sell it again.
- Profit: what the buyer needs to make for taking on the risk and the work.
Put together, it looks like this: ARV − repairs − costs − profit = cash offer.
A simple example
Say a three-bedroom house would sell for about $240,000 once it’s updated. Right now it needs a new roof, a kitchen, flooring and paint, about $40,000 of work. These numbers are only an illustration, but they’re the kind of costs we really run into:
- After Repair Value: $240,000
- Minus repairs: $40,000
- Minus buying and closing costs: about $3,000
- Minus holding costs during 4–5 months of work and selling (taxes, insurance, utilities, loan costs): about $8,000
- Minus selling costs when the fixed-up house sells (commissions and closing): about $15,000
- Minus profit for the risk and the work: about $30,000
- Cash offer: about $144,000
That can feel low next to $240,000. But look at where the money goes. Most of the gap is repairs and the real costs of owning, fixing and reselling a house. Those costs don’t go away. Whoever sells the house fixed up has to pay them, whether that’s you or a buyer.
Watch out for the “70% rule”
Some buyers skip the math and use a shortcut called the 70% rule: 70% of the ARV, minus repairs. On our example house, that’s $240,000 × 70% − $40,000 = $128,000. That’s $16,000 less than the line-by-line number above. A quick rule of thumb is fine for a first look, but it isn’t a substitute for figuring out the real costs on your house. If an offer seems low, it’s fair to ask, “How did you get there?”
Now ask yourself a few questions
Every piece of that formula depends on your house. Before you trust any offer, ask yourself:
- What is my house really worth fixed up? Look at homes that actually sold near you in the last few months, not just what’s listed or what an online estimate says.
- What does it really need? Is it paint and carpet, or roof, furnace, plumbing, electrical or foundation? Big-ticket items change the number more than anything else.
- Is the buyer counting a cost twice? If they’re padding the repairs and taking a big profit and using a 70% rule, the offer can come in much lower than it needs to.
- Who is actually buying it? If the buyer plans to sell your contract to someone else, there’s a second fee in the middle.
If you can answer those with real numbers, you can tell pretty quickly whether an offer is fair.
Not sure about the ARV or the repairs? That’s exactly what we can help with. Call or text Darren at 859-549-4700 (NKY) or 513-286-3900 (Cincinnati), and he can often give you a ballpark right on the phone.
Why a middleman changes the math
Some cash buyers are wholesalers. They put your house under contract and then sell that contract to another investor for a fee, often several thousand dollars or more. That’s a legitimate business, and a good wholesaler can be helpful. But the fee has to come from somewhere, and usually it comes out of your price. On our example house, a $15,000 assignment fee could take the $144,000 down to around $129,000.
We’re not wholesalers on the houses we buy to fix up. We renovate them ourselves with our own contractor, so there’s no middleman fee to cover. That often leaves more room in the numbers for you.
A couple of local costs worth knowing
Whichever way you sell, some costs come with the territory:
- In Kentucky, state law puts a real estate transfer tax on the seller of $0.50 for every $500 of value (KRS 142.050). On a $144,000 sale, that’s about $144.
- In Hamilton County, Ohio, the conveyance fee is $3.00 per $1,000 of the sale price, plus a small transfer fee per parcel (Hamilton County Auditor). On a $144,000 sale, that’s about $432.
When you sell to us, we pay all closing costs, there are no agent fees and no inspection, and we close on your timeline. Just ask any buyer up front who pays what, so there are no surprises at the closing table.
So what is your house’s number?
Here’s the honest part: the formula is simple, but the inputs are where people get it wrong. The ARV depends on your street and the sales around it. The repairs depend on what’s behind the walls. And a cash sale isn’t always the best choice. If your house is in good shape, listing it with an agent often nets more, and we’d tell you that.
Local Honest Homebuyer has been helping Northern Kentucky and Cincinnati homeowners since 2016, and we’d rather you make the right choice than the fast one.
Get your free Two-Number Review
On one short call, Darren gives you two numbers: (1) a ballpark cash offer, often right on the phone, and (2) a rough idea of what you might walk away with if you list after commissions, repairs and costs. He can walk you through how he got each one, then tell you honestly which looks better for you.
Call or text Darren at 859-549-4700 (Northern Kentucky) or 513-286-3900 (Cincinnati), or fill out our short form to get your Free Two-Number Review. No pressure and no obligation, just real numbers for your real house.
Want to run some numbers first? Our free seller calculator lets you see roughly what you’d walk away with if you list, and our post on cash offer vs. listing walks through the same house sold three ways.